Second time making fuel and left shake (Huel+ milk) in fridge after blending. It was in a cup with an opening for sipping. I took it to work and noticed the shake was very hard. First time I did this I used a closed lid with no issue.
I haven’t had the issue you had, but I’ve noticed any leftover dregs in the bottom of the shaker turn to concrete if I don’t close the lid, so I would definitely keep it in an airtight container until I’m ready to drink it.